Book by Marshall Brickman and Rick Elice

Music by Bob Gaudio

Lyrics by Bob Crewe

Directed by Des McAnuff

Review by Dominic Corr

The Edinburgh Playhouse

New Jersey’s concrete alleyways rarely promise longevity. Yet, two decades after its theatrical debut, Jersey Boys, the jukebox chronicle of Frankie Valli and The Four Seasons, still packs auditoriums with unwavering devotion. Arriving at The Edinburgh Playhouse for its anniversary tour, this biographical musical retraces the familiar rags-to-riches trajectory of four working-class Italian-American youths who traded the looming shadows of mafia connections and urban poverty for international pop stardom. But at what cost? It is an engine fuelled entirely by an indestructible catalogue of chart-topping hits – the infectious bounce of “Sherry” to the soaring pathos of “Can’t Take My Eyes Off You” – that have long since woven themselves into the cultural fabric of twentieth-century popular music. This is a guaranteed great night out.

Yet, familiarity can occasionally breed a certain theatrical complacency, and this current touring iteration struggles to capture the sharp, electric oomph that defined its earlier incarnations. Visually, the staging leans heavily toward a minimalist aesthetic; Klara Zieglerova’s scenic design offers little beyond a functional framework and sparse digital backdrops, lacking the immersive soul or theatrical spectacle one might expect from a major milestone production. Though the cartoon illustrations utilised do offer a much-needed ‘pop’ art style of colour and texture. This rigid visual approach is fortunately elevated by Jess Goldstein’s meticulous costuming, which expertly chart the shifting decades from nineteen-fifties sharp tailoring to the iconic flashy red stage suits of their golden era; and by lordy does it make us feel the need to change our wardrobe. Regrettably, technical hurdles puncture the illusion: an uneven sound balance lets the live band swallow up the spoken dialogue and vital vocal delivery, subduing the production’s emotional resonance and leaving key dramatic beats feeling somewhat muted and remote.

These frustrations are all the more regrettable given the immense calibre of the central quartet on stage. Bringing staggering vocal agility to the proceedings, Luke Baker commands the evening as Frankie Valli, effortlessly scaling those dizzying, stratospheric falsetto heights without ever descending into mere impersonation. He is brilliantly bolstered by Toby Miles, who infuses Bob Gaudio with an easy intellectual charm, alongside Lewis Kennedy’s dryly humorous Nick Massi and Scott Goncalves, who steps in with fierce, compelling charisma as the volatile Tommy DeVito. However, despite the undeniable chemistry and vocal pyrotechnics of these performances, Marshall Brickman and Rick Elice’s book rushes through personal tragedies, financial crises, and fractured friendships with such breakneck speed that the production holds its deepest emotions at arm’s length, preventing the narrative from achieving true dramatic depth.

Des McAnuff’s direction maintains a brisk pace, particularly as the narrative shifts into a much snappier second act where internal cracks within the band begin to fracture their golden facade. Yet, the episodic framing device – structured through fragmented perspectives narrated by different members – occasionally stalls the story’s forward momentum, interrupting emotional immersion just as the theatrical stakes begin to rise. Sergio Trujillo’s choreography remains an authentic delight, and has improved with time, injecting slick, synchronised movement into the musical numbers that echoes the polished television performances of the era. It is an inherently crowd-pleasing entertainment that delivers precisely what its loyal fanbase craves, even if the experience feels more like a well-preserved museum piece than a living, breathing theatrical revelation.

The lingering sensation is one of cheerful familiarity rather than transcendent awe; and sometimes that’s what we need. Especially in the colder months, an injection of hot-blooded movement and song. It remains a cracking night out for anyone eager to bask in the timeless sunshine of sixties pop perfection, wrapped in glitter and nostalgic warmth. For all its bumps and surface-skimming, the production succeeds where it matters most: sending an audience out into the Scottish night with those irresistible, golden-era hooks bouncing joyfully through their heads.

---