Review: Mean Girls – The Edinburgh Playhouse

Ensemble of performers holding red trays in a circular formation on a theater stage under red and blue lighting

Book by Tina Fey

Music by Jeff Richmond

Lyrics by Nell Benjamin

Directed and Choreography by Casey Nicholaw

Review by Dominic Corr

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Twenty-two years after Tina Fey’s cult teen comedy first landed on cinema screens, Mean Girls remains stubbornly relevant. Cliques still rule, popularity still comes with a price tag, and teenage social politics remain as brutal as ever. Now touring the UK and arriving at the Edinburgh Playhouse, this stage adaptation delivers plenty of fun, polished performances and an infectious score, even if it occasionally pulls its punches where the original film drew blood.

Mean Girls The Musical arrives in a wash of pink (and not on a Wednesday…), packed with sharp choreography, a talented cast and enough energy to power the city, evident by a mammoth task of reclaiming the audience after a few restarts due to tech issues. While it never quite captures the venomous brilliance that made the film such a phenomenon, it delivers an enormously entertaining evening driven by first-rate vocals and a band that deserves far more attention than it is likely to receive.

The story remains largely familiar. Cady Heron, raised in Kenya and educated at home, arrives at North Shore High School utterly unequipped for the bewildering ecosystem of teenage politics. Drawn into the orbit of Regina George and her loyal followers, she soon discovers that social status can be every bit as ruthless as survival in the wild.

Emily Lane brings warmth and sincerity to Cady Heron, the home-schooled newcomer trying to navigate the bewildering ecosystem of North Shore High. Her journey from awkward outsider to willing participant in Vivian Panka’s Regina George’s toxic hierarchy is handled with assurance, and Lane’s vocals remain consistently controlled throughout a demanding role; and make for a nice counter to Panka’s sharp and edged vocals, which give George that otherworldly influence over the meek.

What separates this production from many touring musicals is the strength of its musical foundations. Jeff Richmond’s score blends contemporary pop, musical theatre and high-octane ensemble writing into something consistently engaging, and under the direction of the show’s musicians, the Edinburgh audience is treated to a rich, full-bodied sound throughout. The band attacks the score with impressive confidence, adding texture and momentum even when the material occasionally threatens to become lightweight. Songs such as Apex Predator, Revenge Party and World Burn land particularly well, but the evening belongs to performers who understand how to use the music to reveal character rather than simply deliver another number.

But it is the supporting cast who truly make fetch happen. It’s always a treat to see stage, screen, and dancing icon Jennifer Ellison on stage, and Max Gill is sensational as Damien. Effortlessly funny without ever straining for attention, he becomes the production’s secret weapon. Every appearance generates laughter, yet his performance never feels like a collection of punchlines. Instead, Gill creates a character audiences genuinely want to spend time with, combining charisma, warmth and excellent vocal control.

Alongside him, Georgie Buckland’s Janis proves utterly magnetic. Possessing one of the strongest voices in the company, Buckland brings grit, defiance and vulnerability in equal measure. Her performance of I’d Rather Be Me is the evening’s standout moment, earning one of the biggest reactions of the night and demonstrating precisely why the song has become such a favourite amongst fans of the show. It is powerful without feeling forced and emotionally grounded without drifting into sentimentality.

And a stand-out for the show; a portable battery of charm and energy are Sophie Pourret as Karen Smith, and Kiara Dario who impresses enormously as Gretchen Wieners. Often reduced to little more than an anxious sidekick, Gretchen emerges here as one of the production’s most layered figures. Dario captures both the comedy and insecurity of a young woman desperate for approval, while her vocal work adds surprising depth to the role. The choreography remains relentlessly energetic, with the ensemble rarely standing still for long. Casey Nicholaw’s staging keeps scenes flowing at pace and ensures the production rarely loses momentum, even during some of the score’s less memorable moments.

If there is a significant criticism, it is that this version of Mean Girls is often more interested in being enjoyable than it is in being truly savage. The original film possessed a wicked streak that cut through every interaction. Here, many of the sharper edges have been smoothed away. Regina is still intimidating, the clique politics still absurd, but the satire occasionally feels softened, reducing the impact of moments that should sting.

Fortunately, the musical compensates with charm, talent and sheer enthusiasm. Supported by a superb orchestra, exceptional vocals and several genuinely standout performances, Mean Girls proves itself to be far more than a nostalgic cash-in; Fetch? Absolutely. This pink-powered musical delivers the goods.


Editor of Corr Blimey, and a freelance critic for Scottish publications, Dominic has been writing freelance for several established and respected outlets such as BBC Radio Scotland, The List, The Scotsman, Edinburgh Festival Magazine, The Reviews Hub, In Their Own League, The Wee Review and Edinburgh Guide. As of 2023, he is a member of the Critic’s Award for Theatre Scotland (CATS) and a member of the UK Film Critics.

A person with curly hair, wearing a patterned sweater, sitting at a wooden table and sipping from a white cup in a cafe setting.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.