Review: No Apologies – The Traverse Theatre, Edinburgh

Performer in an ornate floral dress onstage beside a guitar, cello case, flames, and red theater curtains

Written by Emma Frankland

Directed by Harry Clayton-Wright

Review by Aislinn McSharry

Rating: 4 out of 5.

No Apologies is an exciting exploration of celebrity culture and personal identity, wherein Emma Frankland retells Nirvana‘s 1993 MTV Unplugged Concert, uncovering the cultural overlap of grunge and queer identity, focalised in her theory “Kurt Cobain was trans”. Referred to always as she/her, Cobain is parallelised with Frankland, a trans woman: Frankland dresses as Cobain, sings her music and reimagines her coming-out on stage. Thought-provoking and thoroughly engaging, Frankland investigates the abstract nature of celebrity culture, and its intermingling with our personal histories. Delivered with a blend of wit, honesty, and raw emotion, Frankland’s No Apologies shines.

Growing up in Falmouth under Section 28, Frankland identifies herself with the far-off figure of Kurt Cobain: she listens to Nirvana whilst shopping, makes a vigil in her honour after her passing, and associates Cobain‘s first appearance wearing a dress on the cover of The Face Magazine, with Frankland’s own first experience of wearing a dress. Frankland longs for a trans celebrity to look-up to – what starts with connections to Cobain, becomes a wider exploration of trans identity: Frankland edits the Icarus story, instead depicting a trans woman curtailed by societal expectations.

The jump from Nirvana-related fandom to mythological retellings is initially a little too disorientating, and the simultaneous crashes of thunder and rock music, slightly overwhelming. Nonetheless effective, as the audience experiences theatre on Frankland’s terms, we are launched into this new world, where Frankland illuminates herself only by the chandelier, that she manoeuvres around her. Frankland’s performance is electric. She quickly connects with the audience – from asking about our celebrity heroes at fourteen, to inviting us into her personal experiences – and makes us her concert audience, as she performs her own rock concert and climbs topless through the audience. Hilarious, powerful, and mesmerising, Frankland is also intensely likeable.

The show’s creation from Harry Clayton-Wright‘s direction to the set’s impressive versatility – a clear recreation of the MTV set, littered with backline boxes which also functioned as a wardrobe and a well of water – facilitated Frankland’s presentation of magnificent, empowering theatre.

In just 80 minutes, No Apologies enthrals audiences and leaves profound impact: the audience mourns damage done to trans individuals, whilst empowered by their strength. A theatrical event that encourages thought and feeling, Frankland’s work will stay with you for a long time after the curtain closes.


A young woman with long, blonde hair is sitting at a table in an outdoor setting, smiling and holding a cocktail with mint leaves. She is wearing a pink top and has a bracelet on her wrist. In the background, there are twinkling lights and people enjoying their evening.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.