An Edinburgh Christmas Carol – Royal Lyceum Theatre

From the Novel by Charles Dickens

Adapted and Directed by Tony Cownie

Rating: 4 out of 5.

The ghost of an idea.

This is how Dickens described his significant contribution to the literary and cultural world, particularly as we enter the final days of the year. A story which takes the spectres of remorse, redemption, and guilt and channels them into a sense of community – drawing audiences together with warmth and comfort like few other tales.

And what finer way to replicate this sense of ‘together’ than with An Edinburgh Christmas Carol, a localised (though not dismissive of those outside Auld Reekie) adaptation from Tony Cownie. A returning production following its 2019 outing, the setts of Edinburgh lurch into the past, into a distant realm where Greyfriars Bobby stalks the kirkyard for scraps, the vaults were still inhabited, and the council were as useful as a glass hammer. How things change…

The tale of misery Ebenezer Scrooge’s visit from three spirits which set out to change his avaricious, conniving ways, is undoubtedly one even the tiniest of tots in the Royal Lyceum audience are familiar. From thespian juggernauts to schoolhouse showcases, and even some rather famous puppets and Sir Michael Caine, there are more versions of this tale than there are Humbugs in Cownie’s script.

So, what’s different.

For one, the Lothian twang offers an additional dimension of Scots humour, enabling a playful sense of history and folklore of the region to ripple through the story. Whether it is Scotland’s all too recent history with Christmas as a national Holiday or the shifting of the Ghost of Christmas Past into the Ghost of Christmas Langsyne (Played by Joanne McGuinness).

And sharing the stage with the likes of Scrooge, Fred, Marley, and the Cratchits is one of Edinburgh’s most famous residents: Bobby, the terrier who would never leave his master’s side, even after their passing. One of Simon Auton’s puppets for the show, Hannah Low brings energy and life to the pedigree pup, as much as Stacey Mitchell’s heartfelt Tiny Tim, the other of Auton’s puppets, both bringing tremendous verve and seamless inclusion with Edie Edmundson’s puppetry direction.

And all Christmases have come at once in the guise of Steven McNicoll’s bubbling presence as a host of Dicken’s classical roles. From Mr. Fezziwig, to the aptly named Ghost of Christmas Nouadays, McNicoll brings such Festive cheer into the parts that even the most curmudgeon of misers cannot help but melt their hearts a little at the larger-than-life comedic performances.

But it’s a balanced and even nuanced sense of humour – something crowd favourite Richard Conlon contributes to, the pair striking a fair accord of the comedic content with a rhythm of Dicken’s more sombre elements. Conlon’s dotting father Rab Cratchit offsets his significant role with something more fierce, Scrooge’s intimidating schoolmaster, a violent glimpse at the story’s upcoming sterner moments.

It’s all brought to a unique temperature with Zoe Spurr lighting, remounted by Robbie Butler, which casts a nostalgic glow over Neil Murray’s design: mainly unchanged from the 2019 production. Returning to their spiritual duty is Taqi Nazeer, last mentioned here from the equally haunting Jinnistan, as the Ghost of Ayont, a spectre of the coming years where Murray’s designs shape the usual Reaper visage into that of a Headless Drummerboy – a tightened costume from the past production, and one of the show’s more successful frights. But there’s something worse walking these closes, one man’s footprints echo through the theatre: Crawford Logan’s Ebenezer Scrooge.

Logan is a Scrooge as miserable as ever, but perhaps a touch too approachable in catering to the children and ensuring they follow his redemption. There’s a lack of animosity in Logan’s direction, though the performance is rich with conviction, Edinburgh’s Scrooge isn’t quite as far down the path of villainy as it ought to be, Marley’s warning softened despite Charlie West’s intimidating presence. 

Tonally, a persistent issue of balancing the darkness of Dicken’s classic with the inviting appeal for youngsters strikes an awkward chord. There is no escaping that this is a Ghoulish tale, with effective imagery leaning into the lost souls tormenting Scrooge, or Nicola Roy’s expressive and bittersweet role as Scrooge’s lost-love Belle when paired with Cownie’s more earnest comedy, they can cause moments of disorientation.

In recent years the Royal Lyceum has taken us to Neverland, to Wonderland and even into Narnia, but nothing feels quite as right as being on your doorstep. An Edinburgh Christmas Carol flitters between the Dickensian horrors of its ghostly origins and the traditions of Scottish theatrical festivities, alas its storytelling wobbles somewhat on the snowy setts, but still breathes a sense of community and life into the ghosts of the past, with an all too familiar ring of the contemporary greed we had hoped had ebbed.

Breathes Community and Life

An Edinburgh Christmas Carol runs at the Royal Lyceum Theatre until December 31st.

Tickets for which may be obtained here.

Photo Credit – Stuart Armitt

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s