Written by Peter Quilter 

Directed by Stephen Mear

Review by Libbi Hutton

Theatre Royal

Escaping the crushing weight of the modern world often requires a heavy dose of theatrical escapism, and at the Theatre Royal, Glasgow attempts to deliver exactly that brand of musical medicine are made with Peter Quilter latest creation, Allegra, starring Dame Maurreen Lipman.

Taking a fragile leap into the dizzying space where unbridled optimism collides with the sobering realities of psychological eccentricity, this musical, directed and choreographed with characteristic flair by Stephen Mear, operates as a bittersweet cocktail of neighbourhood comedy and domestic drama, wrapped up in spontaneous outbursts of song. There is an undeniable warmth radiating from the stage, yet Allegra frequently wrestles with its own tonal identity, hovering precariously between a lightweight jukebox fantasia and a deeply felt exploration of a family in crisis.

Unlocking the hidden melodies of ordinary life forms the core of this narrative, which centres on a woman whose psychological eccentricities manifest as an uncontrollable urge to perform. The eponymous heroine, Allegra, lives in a state of perpetual musical theatre, disrupting her quiet village by transforming the local butcher, the baker, the candlestick-maker and the hairdresser into her personal auditorium. This uncontained vibrancy places immense strain on her meeker, accountant brother, Ronen, who employs a Czech care worker to ensure his sister remembers to eat. Beneath the comical encounters with the local constabulary over spontaneous renditions of Annie at a local petrol station, however, lies a much more poignant reality, because these musical outbursts are fuelled by the protagonist choice to ignore her prescribed Ritalin, leading to a brush with a rather bizarre judicial system that demands her colourful mind be medicated into submission.

Finding the perfect equilibrium between featherlight amusement and heavy emotional weight proves to be the greatest hurdle for this new script. While the musical sequences offer a shot of pure adrenaline, including a full-scale rendition of Singin’ in the Rain and flowers bursting from the walls during Tip Toe Through the Tulips, the narrative glosses entirely over the crushing lows of bipolar mania in favour of easy sentimentality. Quilter’s text hammers home the argument that society is simply out to quash joy, relying on weak running gags like stashing a father’s ashes in various food tins, which never quite pays off. The staging leans so heavily on whimsical, dream sequence lighting to build its narrative that the actual storytelling feels entirely out of step with contemporary understanding of mental health, playing a sibling accidentally consuming his sister’s medication for cheap laughs.

Injecting a lifetime of stage craft into a role that could easily slide into caricature is no small feat, and the leading lady manages to ground the evening with singular charisma. Dame Maureen Lipman delivers a performance of immense vitality, channeling the distinct physical comedy and vocal mannerisms of her famous Re: Joyce days to ensure the protagonist feels entirely vibrant. She transitions from brassy cabaret showmanship to moments of quiet, heartbreaking confusion with the practiced ease of a theatrical veteran, ensuring that the audience laughs with her rather than at her. It is a masterclass in comic timing that provides the production with its true emotional compass, finding the twinkle in her eye even when the script forces her to shout obscure numbers from the Great American Songbook at an unprompted crowd.

Sustaining the dramatic stakes of the piece falls heavily on the supporting cast, who must ground the protagonist flights of fancy in a recognizable familial reality. John Middleton anchors the domestic friction beautifully, portraying the weary brother with a protective, deeply moving affection that captures the agonizing toll of keeping a chaotic household together. His chemistry with Elizabeth Bower, who plays the compassionate caregiver Anna with a sharp, grounded warmth born of an upbringing under Soviet rule, provides the necessary friction to balance the whimsy. Meanwhile, Bailey Patrick brings excellent comic energy to the role of the exasperated Officer Rogers, turning what could have been a flat authority figure into a source of genuine humor as he gets dragged into the theatrical delusions.

Navigating the delicate boundaries of human memory and personal expression is a commendable ambition for any commercial comedy, and this production ultimately leaves its audience with a lingering sense of melancholy hope. While the execution remains somewhat uneven, particularly in its dated approach to psychological crisis and its reliance on exhausting eccentric tropes, the underlying message regarding the acceptance of extravagant brilliance remains incredibly potent. It serves as a gentle reminder that some minds are simply too expansive to be confined by standard societal definitions, making for an evening that is corporate in its efficiency, structurally flawed, yet undeniably filled with heart.

---